Upholding the Catholic character of the University of Notre Dame

Classes Expose Students to Sexually Explicit Content Without Consent

What your PATH course description doesn’t tell you
CAMPUS | November 18, 2026

As students prepare to register for their next semester of classes, they make semester-defining decisions while lacking necessary information. Due to unclear course descriptions, students have been exposed to sexually explicit materials with little or no forewarning.

Notre Dame has increased awareness of sexual misconduct in recent years and provided more resources for prevention, such as mandatory modules on consent and optional consent seminars around campus. One of the four elements of valid consent is knowingness, which means that “[t]he person must understand what they’re agreeing to: the basic terms, the nature of the transaction, and any significant risks. Consent based on false or missing information isn’t real consent.”

Consent is not only for sexual actions but also sexual exposure.

The Irish Rover spoke to several students who have been exposed to sexual content in classes without consent. The following student interviewees were granted anonymity out of concern for their privacy.

One English major came forward about a class where students read a short story about a college woman who sells her used underwear to men with fetishes. It was the only story that made her feel uncomfortable, so she thought it was best to read the story and move on. However, she noted that it felt unnecessary to the course and surprising because the title of the short story collection was vague and gave no warning.

Another anonymous student discussed his experience in a writing class required to complete his English major. Since he found that reading the contents of the novel, Martyr!, was at odds with his conscience, he refrained from participating in any class discussions regarding the work. He told the Rover, “When prompted to speak about my silence, I told the professor that I, as a Catholic at a Catholic institution, did not want to engage with material as needlessly graphic and vile as what was being presented to us as irrefutably artistic and in promotion of relativistic ideals.”

Another anonymous student who took the course added, “Martyr! by Kaveh Akbar … had scenes that would make a Catholic uncomfortable—that’s not my issue—it’s the fixation on abuse without focusing on recovery, the ceaseless insistence on the dark without even looking for a light, the idea that because it focuses on an ‘important struggle’ that this book must be saying something important.”

While the syllabus for this course shared with the Rover repeatedly emphasizes creating a “safe space” for conversation and has a section outlining language to be used by students in conversation, there is no mention of graphic content or forewarning to students regarding the required readings of the class.

The student continued, “I and two other classmates who shared these beliefs received the same email for our midterm grade report penalizing it as a lack of engagement. It was an environment hostile and foreign to differing, Catholic views.”

A 2026 alumna told the Rover about her college seminar “Adapting Oz,” which required her to read Wicked by Gregory Maguire. Without any warning from the professor, she had to read explicit sex scenes: “It was uncomfortable and not something I would like to expose myself to, especially in a class I am taking to fulfill a degree requirement to graduate from the University of Notre Dame.”

The alumna explained how the class also discussed fanfiction, which are often sexualized perversions of source text. Overall, the course discussions “emphasized sexual identity, which fell out of line with Catholic thought.” Like the other students, she was not warned by the PATH course description, and “even then, there was no warning about the content in class. We were still expected to read and discuss.” The alumna wished she had researched the required texts on the syllabus before she committed to taking the course.

The philosophy department has also exposed their students to sexual material without prior notice. A senior architecture major told the Rover that her introduction to philosophy class required her to watch TV-MA episodes of Black Mirror: “Multiple episodes involved very explicit heterosexual and homosexual episodes, which were largely irrelevant to the plot of the episode.” This student had no idea of the sexual content before watching the episodes. While she acknowledges how legally she was not exposed to pornography, she was still “extremely uncomfortable viewing this content.” She would skip scenes, but there were times when she had to skip full episodes because the content was so prevalent.

The student’s response to the introduction to philosophy content demonstrated that she felt her consent was violated: “I was shocked that a Catholic university would allow students to view this type of material for required assignments without any prior warning about the content.”

One of the most explicit exposures to sexual content came from the French department. A student told the Rover about when they had to translate the graphic novel Le bleu est une couleur chaude, or Blue is the warmest color. This text was adapted into a film in 2013, containing graphic lesbian sex scenes based on the book, making it one of the 23 NC-17 rated films at the time it was produced in the United States, according to Variety. Throughout the graphic novel, there were several images of groping, sex, and full-frontal nudity of both male and female genitalia.

Unfortunately for French students, this class, which dealt with literary devices in poems, novels, graphic comics, films, etc., was and still is required for French majors and minors. “I have also seen and discussed other 18+ content in two other French courses,” this student told the Rover, “One discussed LGBTQ ideals, prostitution, etc.” All of these texts were to show different accounts of people who migrated to France. “I was not aware when registering for any of these classes,” the student added.

However, the French student was not surprised by the content: “It’s French. The French are much more comfortable discussing their sexuality, and the students in the classes are much more left-leaning. Furthermore, some students are LGBT in these classes, so it is a way to have representation for them at a Catholic school. I was one of the few students uncomfortable reading, hearing, or discussing these topics. But we all mostly laughed.”

The student notes that the issue was centered around the lesbian graphic novel: “There’s pushing the envelope, and then there’s taking it too far.” The professor provided a “PG” version, but it still contained at least 10 pages of nudity, with four pages of lesbian sex. Furthermore, the professor was a man, which added another layer of discomfort to the female student. “Even if it was a hetero couple,” she added to the Rover, “a graphic novel containing sex scenes isn’t the best choice for a mandatory French literary devices class.”

Abigail Smith is a Program of Liberal Studies, theology, and Latin major. Contact her with ideas at asmith78@nd.edu.