Upholding the Catholic character of the University of Notre Dame

Letter to the Editor: American Conservatism is Falling Apart

If conservatives want to win, they must abandon liberal rationalism for traditionalism
POLITICS | November 18, 2026

The 2024 domination of Donald Trump’s Republican party appeared to signal not only the vindication of the conservative movement in the United States, but also the culmination of a broader conservative resurgence against the neoliberal political order that has dominated the West for decades. Just two years later, however, the results of the 2026 midterms indicate that, once again, people are fleeing the American conservative movement.

One need not look at exit polls or approval ratings to know that Trumpist populism is dying. Democratic socialism seems to be replacing the anti-elite philosophy of the “Make America Great Again” movement and the GOP’s appeal to fiscal conservatism has proven illegitimate. Not even a decade after Trump’s triumph over the neoconservatism of the Republican Party’s old guard, the American conservative project appears to have failed again.

Political scientists were quick to blame the Iran War or tariffs, but I contend the cause is something innate within American conservatism itself.

American conservatism continues to fail because it does not understand what genuine conservatism necessitates. Rather than appealing to the goods of preserving inherited traditions and cultivating the mutual loyalties that bind a nation to something substantive, American conservatives have instead advanced a rationalistic alternative—one that amounts to an older iteration of the very liberalism they seek to displace.

American conservatism in its present form is dismissive of the drastic transformations our republic has undergone. It clings to the institutional architecture of American constitutionalism rather than preserving the very political community those institutions were originally designed to protect. As corporations centralize economic power and financial demagogues threaten the liberties of American citizens, the solution of conservatives has been to simply defend the “invisible hand” and side with private enterprise.

In this sense, American conservatism is hardly conservative at all; it is a confused and incoherent collection of competing interpretations of the American founding, united by a relentless faith in its infallibility. For this reason, the movement has not only failed to address the pressing concerns of American citizens, but it has failed to reconcile its inevitable, internal contradictions.

Although it may not have been the explicit reason for many Americans’ support of Trump, the president’s opposition to the Republican establishment appeared to offer the corrective that American conservatism needed: a turn towards traditionalism and away from the rationalistic liberalism of the GOP establishment.

But Trumpism failed for the same reason its conservative predecessors failed: “Make America Great Again” proved not to be a traditional axiom, but a blanket nostalgia for American wealth and prosperity.

Rather than confronting the sclerotic bureaucracy of neoliberalism or the revolutionary impulses of the progressive left, Trump directed his criticism toward an ill-defined “elite class,” simply opposing everything with which this class is associated. Like his ideological predecessor Pat Buchanan, Trump recognized the growing dysfunction of American democracy and understood that an increasingly disillusioned public was beginning to hold the “elites” responsible for its decay.

But both Buchanan and Trump ultimately failed to identify the deeper causes of America’s political dysfunction. Trump did not attempt to address the philosophical failures of our founding in addressing modernity. He instead framed America’s dysfunction and declining economy as the responsibility of tyrannical elites. His solution was to rid America of its deep state—a task that has proved harder than initially imagined.

Trump has neither reformed our broken political system nor fulfilled his promise to “drain the swamp.” Instead, he has become an embodiment of the very elite establishment against which he so vehemently campaigned because he refused to act outside the system and provide alternative leadership.

My explanation may seem shocking, but the reason for this failure is because Trumpism bears an important resemblance to Marx’s politics. Like the Marxist revolutionary, Trump presented American society as divided between a ruling class and an exploited people, declaring himself as the delegate through whom the latter might reclaim its political sovereignty.

Yet, like many Marxist movements before it, Trumpism failed to translate this antagonism into a coherent political alternative. It identified an enemy without adequately identifying the institutional and economic arrangements that sustained its power—all while he continued to rely on broad democratic approval, special interest lobbying, and fusionism to accomplish his agenda.

Trump maintained the Lockeanism of our founding as his guiding principle, and simply sought to restore the system by returning power to the proletariat. Once again, like his conservative predecessors, he placed responsibility on the system itself and not its leaders or tradition. The nation, according to Trumpism, remains a reduced and convenient vessel for popular sentiment and individual rights, and is only an instrumental good to prosperity or power.

If there is one thing that Trump got right, it was this: elites should be held responsible for the nation’s problems.

Unlike Trump, however, I believe that America needs its elites to recover their power. American disorder is not the result of having elites; it is the result of replacing them with a dehumanized system. We need philosophical, ambitious, excellent leaders who are willing to replace the managerial bureaucrats and take back the tradition of the nation. We will restore our republic and make America great again through our elites, through leaders who will be the recipients of honor, trust, and hierarchy. Instead of elevating its weakest, American conservatives need to restore the strong.

If America is to survive, she must reconceive her government to promote leaders who do not place their will in the hands of an impersonal system, but assert it through an active pursuit of the just. We must detach from our egalitarian sensibilities and humble ourselves to place America’s future in the hands of its most virtuous citizens. Ultimately, politics is not merely the exercise of designing a rationalistic system to produce the best foreseeable outcomes; it is the active interpretation of how society ought to pursue its proper ends—a task that requires the judgment and wisdom of capable rulers.

Raymond Webber is a junior from Cleveland, Ohio and politics editor for the Irish Rover. He thinks he is the elite that America needs. Email him for proof at rwebber@nd.edu.