Upholding the Catholic character of the University of Notre Dame

ND Students React to Midterm Elections

Campus split on how GOP should move forward
POLITICS | November 18, 2026

Almost all polls, prediction markets, and pundits predicted that the 2026 midterm elections would be a landslide win for Democrats, and they were vindicated when Republicans lost a historic 42 house seats and nearly every election considered a toss-up. Democrats are projected to walk away from the midterm elections with an estimated 80-seat majority in the House and a 12-seat majority in the Senate, while Republicans have also lost major gubernatorial races in states that had previously been reliably red, including Texas, Ohio, Iowa, Alaska, and Kansas.

Exit polls have shown that issues like the Iran war, corruption, and the economy made the current Republican administration deeply unpopular. President Trump’s approval ratings have declined steadily since his election, and around 42 percent of voters said that they voted explicitly to “rebuke him” according to an AP poll. Experts suspect that such attitudes toward Trump led to many historically popular Republican incumbents—such as Susan Collins of Maine and Greg Abbott of Texas—losing their reelection bids.

Both establishment Democrats and progressive outsiders won their respective elections, but moderates in the party have pointed to their successes in red states as a sign that the progressive left is still “unelectable” at a national scale, even in the midst of a blue wave. Relative underperformances from candidates like Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, combined with unexpected overperformances from moderate candidates like Senator-elect Scott Colom in Mississippi, have resolved concerns for moderates that their influence was declining among the Left.

A unified Democratic Congress with a significant majority means that Trump will finish his second term as a “lame-duck” president, expected to be unable to accomplish much of his agenda without improbable bipartisan support. In the meantime, the Republican party will likely spend the next election cycles searching for the successor to the MAGA movement.

Students at Notre Dame have offered competing explanations for what has come to be characterized as the “blue tsunami” of the midterm elections.

Sam Marchand, Vice President of the Notre Dame College Republicans, told the Rover that, “Republicans failed in the midterms because of the war, full stop. … Ideally, the Republican Party and the administration is able to focus on lowering costs and making it clear to Americans that Democratic socialism is not a viable alternative to anything. … The cumulative inflation generated by both tariffs and the war since January 2025 is less than the country suffered under Biden, but the pocketbooks of voters have a short-term memory.”

Several conservative students who are less positive about the MAGA movement expressed their hope that these results would bring the party to a reckoning. After ten years steering the Republican Party, there are many conservatives who feel that their dislike for Trump has been vindicated with this loss.

Peter Baglow, a freshman, told the Rover, “I think the midterms are an indication of American dissatisfaction with the current establishment whether that be economical, cultural, or ethical. … I also think this is a great moment of recognition of how any unexpected swing in voter-ship is actually an optimistic sign of depolarization across party lines. Further depolarization is what I hope for.”

Another said, “Honestly, I don’t know what to make of it. I don’t love that Democrats won, but I am glad that this Republican party is facing a reckoning.”

A freshman, who supported Democrat candidates, said, “I would consider myself more conservative if the Republican party found a way to be less controversial and more considerate of normal American citizens.” He added, “If there was a way to bring the Republican party back to the era of McCain, I’d consider voting for them for sure. As it is, the Democrats just need to win; Trump is just totally crazy, honestly.”

The College Democrats of Notre Dame gave a statement to the Rover, saying “The midterm results exemplified a resounding rejection of Donald Trump and the Republicans’ agenda … the American people decided enough was enough. Democrats now fully control both houses of Congress and will put the brakes on a runaway train that has been the Trump Administration. It will be up to the current administration to listen to voters’ demands and actually begin to work for the people.”

Notre Dame students are split on the results of the midterms, as one would expect, but most seem to echo the sentiment that the Republican party needs change.

Anthony DuVinage is a first-year majoring in PLS and Political Science. He can usually be found mulling over his intense dislike of AI (please don’t kill me). If you’d like to discuss something besides politics, he can be reached at aduvinag@nd.edu.